Monday, 21 April 2014
June Loves "The Festival By The Sea"
I admit shamefully that it was the first the cover art that drew me in to this book, but it was the concept of a writer's group and festival that clinched the deal. (Also, I didn't realise it was the illustrator behind the Penguin Children's Classics collection I received last Christmas).
After days of rain, there was finally a sunny afternoon that was perfect to indulge in reading a book with a sea-side setting. However, I failed to be drawn in, and putting the book down, I had an inner discussion with myself about whether or not I wanted to read this book, which I wasn't enjoying, or simply return it.
It is not entirely to my regret that I continued, but unfortunately, even as I turned to the last page, I failed to see any merit in the characters or story, at least for me personally.
The only character thoroughly enjoyed was the Dog (a dog), who is shown as having conversations with the protagonist (and it is probably harsh of me to say that I think he is the only character with character).
I can't say the protagonist was inconsistent, but there were times I thought I knew what kind of woman she was, only for her to turn that on her head, and not in a good way. While not preachy or self-righteous, she does carry a hint of self importance as the director, where for me, a down to earth character would be far more appreciated. The ending was predictable. The life-changing decisions hinted near the start of the book are easy to guess the outcomes for. The friends who are mentioned constantly throughout the pages seem to be left with loose threads though. I think the story would work better if we were given insight into the lives of all the characters, with more significance placed on and more Time given to the main protagonist. I think a lot of the side characters were more interesting and relatable than the one we were forced to follow every step of the way.
As a slice of life novel, following the day to day routine of a middle-aged woman as she goes about her business, the story is slightly lacking. A festival planning isn't the most interesting story with only pale characters to back it up. Fresh perspectives would lend the plot much needed story.
Although Loves paints a variety of distinct characters, I felt they weren't fleshed out and I only got to know them as if I were a stranger briefly visiting their lives, rather than an investment in a world and its people I will carry forever.
I'm not dismissing this book entirely, as it is still charming and at times funny, but I doubt I will ever think back on Shelley Beach with fond memories the way other places of fiction inspire.
If you enjoy light novels and middle-aged protagonists, this may be the perfect novel for you. It is set in Australia, but failed to register with me as such (although I might be bias to the more lush green and dusty scenery).
I can't recommend this, but at the same time, it isn't terrible. If you are running out of things to read and have this on the shelf, then get around to it.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment